How to Make a Smoked McRib Sandwich

If you’ve read any of my other content, you know I’m not very good at leaving good enough alone. A McRib is fine, but a homemade Smoked McRib Sandwich is better.

I love baby back ribs, and most of the time I’m content just eating them right off the bone. There’s debate as to which method is the best for cooking baby backs, but I typically follow the “321 method or a close variation of it.

Before we talk about how to make the sandwich, let’s talk about how to make the ribs.

Smoked McRib Sandwich Recipe - BBQ pork rib sandwiches - smoked low and slow, and then placed on a sourdough roll. This is a simple pellet grill recipe. Tender smoked ribs - pickled onions - #traegergrills #traegerrecipes #traeger #smokedmeats #bbqrecipes
Every bite of this bbq pork rib sandwich is loaded with flavor

What is the 321 Method for Ribs?

The reason so many people like the 321 method is because of the simplicity of the process. The numbers stand for the number of hours in each step.

  • Three hours meat side up, at 180 or 225
  • Two hours wrapped in foil with butter, brown sugar, and apple juice (temp 225)
  • One hour unwrapped meat side up, brushing barbecue sauce on at the beginning (temp 275)

I do my best to follow this method every time I cook ribs, and the results are always good. Sometimes I’ll cook them a little longer than three hours in the beginning to build the bark, other times, I’ll extend the two-hour portion to two and a half to really tenderize the meat.

Smoked McRib sandwich before it was sliced
Check out this smoked McRib sandwich! BBQ pork ribs, with sourdough, and pickled onions.

As long as you follow the rough framework, your results will be good.

Meat Side Up, or Bone Side Up?

Some people will recommend going meat side down during the wrapped portion, but I prefer not to do this. As long as the meat is tightly wrapped in foil, I’d prefer to keep the ribs bone side down. The moisture in the wrap will steam the meat, and if you have the ribs meat side down they’ll be sitting in all that juice and could turn to mush… That is not the desired doneness we are looking for!

We are, however, looking for ribs that are tender enough to slide the bones out clean. For that reason, I cooked the rack of ribs for BBQ pork rib sandwiches following a 3-3-1 method.

Smoked McRib Sandwich Recipe

There are a few things you should do before you throw your ribs on the smoker. The first step is to square up the ribs and trim away any excess fat. After you’ve squared up the ribs remove the silver skin. Rub the rack with olive oil or mustard, and then apply a generous amount of rub. This short video shows the process.

After the ribs are prepped, set up your smoker to cook at 180 degrees. I used oak pellets for this cook, but cherry or apple pellets pair well with pork ribs too. Place the ribs meat side up in the smoker, and let them take on smoke for 3 hours.

Wrapping Baby Back Ribs

After three hours remove your ribs from the smoker, and place the rack meat side up on two pieces of foil that are approximately double the length of the ribs. Cube up a stick of butter and place on top of the ribs, followed by a 1/4 cup of brown sugar, and then sprinkle some more rub on top.

Close up the foil tightly around the ribs, being careful not to puncture the foil with the rib bones. Situate the foil so the seam is at the top. Before you seal it shut, pour a 1/4 cup of apple juice in as well. Pour the juice so it runs down the inside of the foil instead of directly on the meat. You don’t want it to wash away any bark that has established.

Turn the heat up on your smoker to 225 degrees, and let the ribs cook for an additional 2 and a half to 3 hours. This is longer than normal, but we want to be able to pull the bones clean at the end of this cook.

After three hours carefully remove the ribs from the foil. There’s gonna be a significant amount of moisture and steam in that foil pack, so it’s best to open it over a cookie sheet to prevent a mess.

Place the ribs back on the smoker meat side up, and brush on your favorite barbecue sauce. Turn the heat up to 275 and let the ribs cook for an additional 30 minutes to an hour.

Pulling Bones for Smoked McRib Sandwiches

When the ribs are done cooking pull them off the smoker and place the rack on a large cutting board to rest for ten minutes. Be careful! These ribs are gonna be super tender.

While the ribs are resting slice a large loaf of bread in half. I used sourdough, but what you choose is up to you.

BBQ pork rib sandwich sliced up
This smoked McRib sandwich was so damn tasty

Flip your ribs over, meat side down, and slowly pull each of the bones out. You might have to wiggle them a little bit, but they should slide right out, clean as a whistle. After you’ve removed all the bones, flip the rack over, and place it on the bread. I added pickled onions, and then another layer of bbq sauce before adding the top piece of bread and slicing it up to serve.

There you go! Simple and delicious šŸ™‚ The best smoked McRib sandwich you’ve ever had.

Love ribs? Check out my recipes for Honey Garlic Baby Backs or Beef Ribs.

BBQ Pork Rib Sandwich
Print Pin
5 from 4 votes

Smoked McRib Sandwiches

Everyone has tried that rib sandwich from the famous fast food place, but that sandwich doesn’t hold a candle to this one. Smoked low and slow, the incredible flavor you get is out of this world!!
Cuisine American
Keyword Baby Back Ribs, bbq sandwich, pork ribs, rib sandwich
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 6 hours 30 minutes
Additional Time 10 minutes
Total Time 6 hours 50 minutes
Servings 6
Calories 450kcal
Author Nick


  • 1 rack pork baby back ribs
  • 3 tbsp bbq rub
  • 1 tbsp olive oil
  • Pickled Onions
  • 1 loaf Sourdough Bread Sliced in half longways
  • 2 tbsp Barbecue Sauce
  • 8 tbsp butter
  • 1/4 cup apple juice
  • 1/4 cup brown sugar


  • Square up the ribs, and remove the silverskin. Rub both sides with olive oil, and then apply 2 tbsp of the rub.
  • Place the ribs in your smoker meat side up and let cook at 180 degrees for three hours.
  • Remove the ribs from the smoker and double wrap with foil. Before sealing add the butter, apple juice, brown sugar, and the remainder of the rub.
  • Place the ribs back in the smoker and let cook at 225 degrees for an additional 2.5-3 hours
  • Carefully remove the ribs from the foil and place back in the smoker. Brush with barbecue sauce and turn up the heat to 275. Let the ribs cook for about 30 more minutes.
  • Remove ribs from smoker and let rest for 10 minutes
  • After the ribs have rested, carefully remove each of the bones, and then place the rack on top of your bread. Generously top with pickled onion and more barbecue sauce, slice, and serve.


Calories: 450kcal
Please note that some of the links in this post are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through them I may make a small commission, at no additional cost to you.
Iā€™m a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.
Click here for my full Affiliate Disclaimer

One Reply to “How to Make a Smoked McRib Sandwich”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating